Photo: Lopanayak · CC BY-SA 4.0
Palak Paneer
An Indian vegetarian curry of paneer cheese simmered in a smooth spinach gravy. Blanch the spinach briefly to keep it vivid green — serve with rice or naan (tofu works if you can't find paneer).
Ingredients
- Spinach · blanched300 g
- Paneer · cubed (or tofu/halloumi)200 g
- Onion · chopped1
- Tomato · chopped1
- Garlic · minced3 cloves
- Ginger · minced1 tbsp
- Green chili · optional1
- Ghee (or butter/oil)2 tbsp
- Cream · + more to finish3 tbsp
- Spices
- Cumin seeds1 tsp
- Turmeric0.5 tsp
- Ground coriander1 tsp
- Garam masala1 tsp
- Salt1 tsp
Steps
- ⏲ 5 min
Blanch the spinach 30 seconds, shock in cold water (to keep it green), then blend smooth.
- ⏲ 3 min
Cube the paneer and lightly brown it in ghee, then set aside (optional; skip for softer paneer).
- ⏲ 5 min
In the same pan, fry the cumin seeds until fragrant, then cook the onion until golden.
- ⏲ 4 min
Add the garlic, ginger, and chili, then the tomato, turmeric, coriander, and salt; cook until the oil separates.
- ⏲ 3 min
Add a splash of water with the paneer, cream, and garam masala and simmer 2–3 minutes.
Stir in the blended spinach and heat it just through, 1–2 minutes, without boiling (overcooked, it dulls). Serve with rice or naan.
Variations
- Tofu version: Use firm tofu instead of paneer (vegetarian, easier to find; for a vegan version also use oil instead of ghee and coconut or cashew cream instead of cream).
- Saag paneer: Mix in other leafy greens like mustard leaves.
- Lighter: Use yogurt instead of cream, or skip it.
- Spicier: Adjust with more chili or chili powder.
Tips
- Blanch briefly and shock the spinach to keep a vivid green.
- Brown the onions for sweetness and depth.
- Brown the paneer or add it plain — your choice (browning helps it hold shape).
- Don't overcook the spinach — it loses color and freshness.
- No paneer? Tofu or halloumi work well as substitutes.
More detail and the reasons why (5)
- That paneer does not melt is this dish's premise. Mozzarella explains the same material from the opposite end: an acid-set curd "has almost no calcium bridging left to loosen, so heat never makes it flow", and past about pH 5.2 a curd "will not stretch at all, only crumble — which is the state the paneer in palak paneer is in." Curdling milk with acid near boiling takes the calcium that braced each casein micelle out with the whey, and that network can never re-flow. Which is what lets it be cubed and simmered and still be there.
- The same starting point as rasgulla. That page says it outright: paneer is also milk curdled with acid, and everything after differs — paneer is pressed hard into a firm block while chhena is not. One curd, and whether you press it decides between a cheese you chew and a dough you boil in syrup.
- Frying holds the shape and costs you texture. The surface proteins tighten further, so the cubes keep their edges in the gravy and go rubbery in exchange. Ten minutes in warm salted water after frying softens the inside again while the crust holds. Halloumi, the other substitute, is far saltier — start with none of the recipe's salt.
- The spinach half is explained elsewhere. Why it is blanched and shocked is in blanching and sigeumchi-namul. What this dish adds is an order: the puréed spinach goes in last and is only warmed through. Boil a purée and the acids released from the broken cells displace the magnesium at the centre of the chlorophyll, and it is olive-drab within minutes.
- Switching cream for yoghurt means dropping the heat. Cream carries enough fat to survive a simmer; yoghurt curdles, exactly as dairy and heat sets out. Off the heat, a spoonful at a time, stirring.
The basics behind this dish
- Browning and the Maillard ReactionMeat fails to brown for one of three reasons: it is wet, the pan is cool, or you put too much in at once. Plus how the brown film stuck to the pan becomes your sauce.
- Cooking Meat: Temperature, Resting, and Cutting Against the GrainDoneness is a core temperature, not a number of minutes. What resting actually does, how to handle a thick cut, and why the direction you slice changes the texture.
- Knife Skills: Grip, Cuts, and Why Size MattersHow you hold the knife matters more than how fast you cut. The pinch grip, the claw hand, and why uniform size is a cooking decision rather than a cosmetic one.
More of the same kind
More from this country
✏️ Improve this recipe
Sign in to edit.
Written with AI · how we check it · Edit history
https://cookiki.com/en/r/palak-paneer · cookiki · User contributions are licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.